Three Strikes, Newsroom, Three Strikes

Three episodes is the standard hook-me-or-I’m-out window I give new shows. That’s about all the time I’m willing to spare for something unproven. My attention span shrinks by the day, but some of my favorites, old and new (The Wire, Girls), took more than the first 8 seconds to convince of their merit.

Last night, I hit the three-episode mark with Aaron Sorkin’s The Newsroom, and ladies and gentlemen, the jig is officially up. It’s not that the show is irredeemable, it’s just that my time is better spent on Next Food Network Star. Yes, The Newsroom is that bad.

There are many problems included but not limited to epically long and boring monologues, terrible musical selections, a distorted nostalgia for a past that doesn’t exist, and not a single likeable persona among the bunch. But the biggest problem, which I’m not the first to note, is Sorkin’s attitude towards The Women.

In the world of The Newsroom, women are shrill, spastic, pathetic, manic, melodramatic, jealous, petty, technologically incompetent, unprofessional, obsessive, preoccupied with “saving” men, frantic, disorganized, bossy, irritable, and above all, frazzled and desperate. They exist as two-dimensional paper dolls onto which the men can project their opinions and reinforce their own (admittedly limited) identities.

After I finished episode 3 last night, I returned to Season 1 of Friday Night Lights, which I have been rewatching because I miss the Taylors and summer sucks for television. This is how emotional drama about the American experience is done. The character that would be the easiest to pigeon-hole, the sweet and sassy coach’s wife, is as robust and multi-faceted as the rest (a credit both to the writer and the insanely talented Connie Britton).

I’ve talked about this before regarding Game of Thrones and I’m going to quote myself, because today I’m just that cool:

Despite the confines of their societal roles, the women and girls in Game of Thrones have lives as ethically complex and emotionally difficult as the knights and swordsmen. The roles of wife, mother, sister, daughter are never one-note labels, but mere pieces of very nuanced portraits of human life. Just because these characters are limited by the inequality of their environment doesn’t make their stories any less rewarding.

This is a lesson Aaron Sorkin seems to be forgetting. In the most recent episode, the nervous, manic Maggie suffered a panic attack, from which the heroic Jim rescued her. The panic attack could have been a window into Maggie’s mind and experience, instead it was used to showcase Jim’s skill and to teach us about his history as a reporter embedded with troops.

Sorkin has already chosen which characters he finds independently interesting, and surprise of all surprises, they look a lot like him.

Related Post: White guy, white girl, non-white guy, how to fake diversity on television.

Related Post: Some characters from West Wing will always be my favorites.

Advertisements

5 Comments

Filed under Art, Gender, Hollywood, Media

5 responses to “Three Strikes, Newsroom, Three Strikes

  1. Pingback: Things that are not the opposite of misogyny | rosiesaysblog

  2. Pingback: Is Parks and Rec the Most Feminist Show on TV? | rosiesaysblog

  3. Ok but what about Mackenzie who is the entire driving force behind the show, she is the reason they decide to report the news, or Sloan who is the smartest person on the show yet completely socially awkward. Maggie is a mess because some people are messes. At work she is either contributing something terrific or bumbling incompetently, and yeah Jim’s relationship with her is of the Damsel in Distress Variety, but that’s ok. Maggie is complex she doesn’t end up with Jim and she often is a damsel in distress that’s not to say that a man couldn’t also be in need of saving look at Will. I think the show continues to reinforce the idea that Maggie can not be saved by Jim, and she chooses not to be, obviously that’s something she has to do herself. Maggie’s just a fantastic example of a girl who has yetr to grow in to herself.

    • I gotta admit, I gave it three eps and called it quits. Maybe I should go back, but my initial impression was so poor that I gave it up.

      • Yeah I may be slightly defensive because I think the show is awesome, different tastes and such. Anywho I do genuinely think though that the females are written well, realistically, and are in their own way empowering.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s